Best card in the bunch? This one here:

Not bad for a couple of discount junkers.


Now this is a memorabilia card. Fluffy clouds, bunting, a future Hall of Famer and the card itself is thick as a brick. Seriously, the card is thicker than an entire pack of Bowman Chrome. The relic piece is from a base, which is kind of weird, but if you look at the back things get a little better.
There's not only a picture of the actual base, but they have listed the exact game where it was used. Not a good game unfortunately, as the Mets pounded the Braves in the home opener at Shea. It's still pretty unique and it's cool to see the exact game the relic was taken from. My Chipper collection just increased by one which is highly appreciated.
Ah, Mario understands that for a few players it doesn't matter what uniform they are wearing, they are always a Brave. Maddux is definitely one of those players. He's practically a Brave here anyway. Just take the R in Padres, move it after the P, add an extra bump to the P to make it a B, then mangle the D until it looks like a V and you've got Braves. There's four Maddux cards in here, including three from Chrome.
If I had unlimited money and time the Heritage Chrome set would be one I would chase down a card at a time. The Chrome cards really look good with the '59 design. I'm kind of worried about next year's set though, I love the 1960 design, but I remember seeing some Chrome Wrestling cards that also used the '60 design and they were not attractive. Might be the wrestling guys on 'em, or maybe they were just plain ugly. The jury's out on that one, we'll just have to wait and see. One card that looks absolutely awesome though is the...
Daaaaaaaamn these cards look nice! Even the photo with a stone faced Greg about to get caught in a storm at spring training looks good when it's blue refractorized. I want to go out and buy a box of Chrome now just for the blues. But wait, there's...



On a completely unrelated note, why oh why does this man not play first base??? His coach should be charged with malpractice for putting him at shortstop. Oh well, I Don't Give A Darn.
I was most excited to pull Larry Doby. The Buzz Aldrin of MLB integration was a great player just like Jackie Robinson was, but never got the accolades. Every card set with a Larry Doby card in it is a good card set.
Captain Hook, Ralph Kiner and the biggest free agent flop in several decades. It's almost as if Andruw sold his soul to the devil like in the movie Damn Yankees and he turned into an old man all of a sudden.
This card here made the box worth it. Powder blue jersey with a maroon helmet on a yellow background. Gorgeous.
The president cards in this set suck, but TR is my favorite president so I can't complain.
He's not winning the Cy Young this year, but he has a Home Run result for the game on the back of his card. Chicks dig the longball.
Beckett's arm hasn't fallen off, which is a good sign. I've had very good luck pulling baseball related Sport Royalty cards, which is fine and dandy with me. The bummer here is that while cards 301-330 are more short printed than the rest (I've pulled as many of them as I have autographs) I've managed to get two Tony Gwynns and no one else. But, hey, it's Tony Gwynn.
The minis are frustrating the crap out of me. They are landing at only three per blaster and if you get a Berk Ross inset then you only get two. Why the hell aren't these one per pack??
I've got a big pile of these damn things and these are the very first ones from the '40s that I've received. I was beginning to think Upper Deck put them all in the high-falootin' expensive packs that I never buy. Joe Gordon is a candiate on this year's Veteran's Committee Hall of Fame ballot too, which is very cool.
Parade of Champions?? LaDainian ain't won shit. And no, an ESPY award does not count as a Champion. I'm ashamed to put this card in the same page as my Reggie Jackson, Bobby Orr and Michael Jordan Berk Ross cards.
I picked up a couple of blasters this week, one Goudey, one A&G. Both were weird in their own special way. One frightening, one just odd. I'll add two more data points onto the Dinged Corners Front Loaded Blaster Theory and post some quick recaps with oddities here.
Nothing too special about this box. I got ten cards I needed for the set, I needed all four state cards pulled (yaaay) and I already had all four short prints (boooo). The weirdness came in with the mini cards. Three packs had two minis each in them. Nothing overly special about the mini cards, I just got three bonus minis and beat the odds on pulling A&G backed cards. Since I was gypped out of a mini card in my last box it's just evening things out a bit. I also learned that Gambia it known as THE Gambia, as opposed to a bootleg knockoff Gambia. Accept no substitutes...
Another fairly pedestian box with the exception of pulling both Sports Royalty cards in the same pack. That was a nice feeling, as I not only got an extra SP, but they were both real live baseball players to boot. When I looked at them though, I noticed something odd. The back of the Gwynn card was in green ink instead of black and the card stock was darker than the Jeter card. I thought "that's odd" moved on to the next pack and then noticed they were all like that.
Half of each pack in the box was printed on slightly darker card stock than the rest. And I mean very sightly, but just enough to be noticeable. The first 4 cards the pack were light, the rest with the exception of a couple of short prints were dark. This is how red and green back variations were inserted into last year's packs. I thought, oh hell naw, not another goofy parallel. However, I checked my other Goudeys and the only dark back cards I found were a couple of short prints, such as this '36 card of Prince:
I don't know if I managed to catch a box that was packed up right when UD changed the roll of cardboard on the printing press or what, but the thought of another stupid parallel makes me queasy. Topps actually did have a light/dark back variation in their '56 Heritage set but they were mimicing the original set and were nice enough to advertise the fact. The silver lining in all this is if there does happen to be a variation, it's hard enough to tell between the two so that you can just ignore it.

There are too many short prints in this set and pulling a card of a President just seems like a complete waste. Even pulling a really good president like Jefferson is frustrating. The guy's face is on currency, I don't need him eating up a card that could have been an athlete. I wasn't crazy about the 60 card Sport Royalty subset at first, but now that I have a couple in my hands they're actually pretty neat. The fact that Chipper Jones was deemed worthy to be in the set makes it a little more special in my mind. Presidents? Meh. There have been President cards all over the place for years. It's time to give them a rest and I wish one of my 4 short prints per box would have been of a baseball player and not a statesmen.
The Sport Royalty cards are sweet, but the original sized mini versions are doubly so. They just have that little difference to them that makes me feel like I'm holding an original card from the '30s. Jack Nicklaus is a damn good card too, the man won eleven minus five (that's six) Green Jackets. Another cool thing about this card is the little "Golden Bear" logo on the back mixed in amongst the legalese. The color variations on the back are a little unnecessary, but not as annoying as the fact that the minis are not one per pack. I have a near set of the T205 minis and I never paid much attention to the back advertising variations. A mini's a mini. I just wish they were a little easier to get.
A note on the Fukudome rookie card: So far, Kosuke has exactly one actual rookie card in a Topps product and it's a severely short printed card. The rookie I pulled out of this pack is my sixth one out of various Upper Deck packs. If you're a Cubs fan, why on earth would you rip a pack of Topps right now? Right now I am seriously debating on whether I should bite the bullet and go all out on building the '36 subset in all mini cards. I know my '36 Goudeys and the standard size cards don't look right. Hell, I'm kind of puzzled that UD didn't have the foresight to insert premium sized '36 Goudey cards as box toppers. The originals were printed on photo paper, it wouldn't have been too much trouble to throw a sheet of paper on the top of every box and it would have been a fun reason to buy a hobby box. Hell, they could have thrown one of the cards on the copier, set it to 200% and just let it run. Whammo! Instant box toppers! Right now there is zero incentive to buy Hobby packs as they are identical to these retail packs except for the 1:18 shot you have at an autograph. You're paying a 40 dollar premium on a hobby box for one autograph. Set builders: buy retail. Seriously.
I knew it would happen eventually. 2008 Goudey is the official moment when the Yankee Stadium Legacy cards became completely tedious. First off, pulling a glossy, foil stamped card out of a pack of old-school cardboard cards is jarring. It's the exact same feeling as pulling an A-Rod Bullshit Waste of Space card out of a pack of Allen & Ginter or Heritage last year. It's also the last card in the pack, which is where the short prints live, so when you pull a Yankee card there it's as if a short print was taken away from you. Thankfully there was a mini card in this pack to soften the blow, but that's not the case in every pack. To add insult to injury, I already have a Whitey Ford insert with this very photo on it, card 3132 to be exact.
Of course the flip side of the Yankee Stadium Legacy hate is the fact that ripping a pack with no inserts whatsoever feels even worse. I feel a little hypocritical complaining about pulling only base cards when I am an advocate for building sets and collecting cards for cards sake. The thing is, Goudey's main rival is Allen & Ginter. They have short prints in their set at the same odds as in Goudey. However, there are eighty less of them. So if you don't get a SP, it doesn't hurt hat bad. Plus, even if you don't pull an SP, there's going to be a mini card in the pack. So ripping a pack of A&G will net you something, even if you have the entire set filed away in a binder. This pack is great right now, as I need all 8 cards for my set. In a couple of months when I have the complete base set and a bunch of SP's this pack is a complete waste of three bucks. Packs like this are why a few months from now I'll still be buying all the A&G I can find on the shelves while I let the Goudey collect dust because I don't want to get 8 more doubles. On the other hand, who wouldn't want multiple copies of Hanley Ramirez activating his Wonder Twin Powers?
Ah, much better. A real SP of a two time MVP. No WNBA logos on the back though. Don't they do licensing? I guess they'll take any publicity they can get.
Best pack in the box by orders of magnitude. See A Pack A Day for more details on this one.
Ok I just can't complain about pulling any Yogi card from any pack. If I spent a couple grand on an original unopened Piedmont cigarette pack from 1909, and I opened it up and pulled out a gem mint Topps206 Yogi Berra mini card, I'd consider that money well spent. Ok, so I spent thousands of dollars on a card that's worth maybe a buck, but on the bright side I would have had the most epic Bipping of all time. This pack also shows off the absolute best aspect of this set, the base set retired legends. I don't know about you, but pulling a Hall of Famer like Pee Wee Reese or Warren Spahn out of a 2008 set is like pulling an insert to me.
I really really really like the fact that retired legends get cards in the base set this time. This fact alone ensures that I will build this set despite the insane amount of short prints and UD's stinginess with the mini cards. Palmer's a Hall of Famer, the background is appropriately orange and I thankfully cannot see Jim's jockey shorts.
How to become immortal:
Oh yeah, I like this set. I prefer the mini cards though. I wonder how hard it would be to complete the mini '36 set? Probably harder then completing the original '36 set. UD got it right though, check out the back:
Foul / 11ɐq I still haven't seen a hit on one of these cards... It's a good game if you're really into strikeouts and walks.
The eyes...
THE EYES..........
YESS!!! I GOTS KNUCKSIE! Hey, this card seems familiar...
Shenanigans! Recycled photos! Upper Deck is lazy! This bit of coolness makes up for it though:
Yeah! '70s lowercase A logo! I'm looking forward to seeing what logo they use on the Spahn card now.
Yay, short printed soccer player. Now I only need 58 more Sport Royalty cards for the set. By the way, if anyone pulls the Chipper Sport Royalty, name your price.
Why the hell aren't these one per pack? Seriously, Upper Deck. You get so close to putting out a great set and then you pull something mind numbingly stupid like this and screw it all up.
Chad Cordero looks like the Joker on this card. A little makeup, some green hair and maybe a machine gun and bam - instant Joker.
I have had insanely good luck pulling Reggie cards from both this and last year's Goudey. The back is printed in black ink, but I'm not sure if that means anything. So far all the short prints I've pulled have black ink except the 1936 Ortiz card which has green ink. At least I think it's green. Upper deck has me paranoid about ink variations.
I got an Orioles Bonanza in these four packs.
A mini card in every other pack frustates me. Making ink variations for the mini cards drives me to despair.
I finally pulled a LaRoche card to send Brian. Good thing he's not a short print. This is the second straight year, Upper Deck has had Adam staring off into space on his Goudey card.