#1 Heritage Young Hill Stars
This is a pretty cool card, although I'm almost certain James Shields is pasted in. The original Young Hill Stars card from 1960 featured Jack Fisher, Milt Pappas and Jerry Walker.
#2 Heritage High Joakim Soria
Forget the fact that this guy has his own trading card set, The best part about this card is on the back:
#3 Goudey Mark Teahen
Ordinarily the sheer blueness of this card would be good for a high score, but poor Mark got caught up in a bad matchup. Story of this career, really.
fifth round, yadda yadda, scores...
2009 Heritage 12 - 2009 Goudey 11 - 2008 Heritage High Series 11.